This alarming information was released coinciding with the meeting of the EU Competent Authorities expert group for regulation on persistent organic pollutants (POPs), which will discuss rules for recycling and definitions of wastes containing persistent organic pollutants (POPs), such as polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) and dioxins. “To prevent the presence of highly toxic substances in toys, the EU and its member states have to withdraw their registration for recycling exemptions in the Stockholm Convention and introduce stricter limits for POPs in waste. We also need to get brominated dioxins listed among chemicals regulated under the Stockholm Convention,” explains Jindrich Petrlik, the main author of the study, Executive Director of Arnika - Toxics and Waste Program, and Co-Chair of IPEN’s Dioxin, PCBs, and Waste Working Group.
Brominated dioxins are highly hazardous chemicals that are known to affect brain development, damage the immune system and unborn children, increase the risk of cancer and risk disruption of thyroid function. They occur as by-products in brominated flame retardants and as a result of the incineration of brominated wastes and materials. “Bioassay analysis of dioxin-like activity has confirmed surprisingly high toxicity of recycled plastics,” said Peter Behnisch, one of the co-authors of the study and the director of BioDetection Systems, a laboratory based in Amsterdam, Netherlands. “To our knowledge, this is the first publicly available study to show brominated dioxins in children’s products,” added Peter Behnisch.
The consumer products analyzed were bought in seven countries on four continents, and had been previously analyzed for the content of another group of toxic chemicals, PBDEs. The significant contamination of children’s products by dioxins ranged from 56–3,800 pg WHO-TEQ/g. In at least one sample from each country, values in the order of hundreds of pg WHO-TEQ/g were found, as is the case with fly ash and bottom ash from waste incinerators. It did not matter whether the toy was obtained in Latin America, South Asia, Africa, or the European Union.
The highest concentration of dioxins was found in a toy purchased in Germany. It was also the only sample that exceeded Germany’s legislative limit for brominated dioxins. "But it does not mean that other toys can be considered safe. The German limit does not include all the toxic brominated dioxin congeners. As brominated dioxins are in recycled products as impurities accompanying brominated flame retardants, it would be faster to prevent their further spread by tightening the limits for PBDEs in wastes to a level of 50 mg/kg, which would ensure elimination of dioxins from recycled plastics. This is the only way how to avoid toxic recycling,” said Manuel Fernandez, Chemical Policy Officer in BUND/Friends of the Earth Germany.
“Building a non-toxic environment for children is the absolute health and economic priority of today,” said Genon Jensen, executive director of the Health and Environment Alliance (HEAL). “That’s why a circular economy has to contribute to health prevention, meaning hazardous substances have to be taken out of the loop, and at the same time, no derogation on health standards should be allowed for recycled materials.”
“Chlorinated dioxins released decades ago in the Seveso disaster and Agent Orange has caused severe public health impacts that still continue today. Brominated dioxins are as toxic as their chlorinated cousins and they clearly should not be present in any consumer product, and especially not in children’s products,” said Joe DiGangi, Senior Science and Technical Advisor of IPEN.
Advocates stress that the loophole in the current legislation is not only bad for Europe, but also for the developing world. Europe now sends 15-50% of its e-waste either illegally or as used electronics, with hazardous levels of brominated flame retardants, to less developed countries in Asia and Africa, where it continues to persist and contaminate in the form of recycled plastics.
The research on the Toxic Soup: Dioxins in Plastic Toys study was conducted by Arnika, IPEN, BUND and HEAL. Samples were collected in the following UN regions and countries: Czechia, France, Germany, and Portugal (European Union), Argentina (GRULAC), India (Asia Pacific Region) and Nigeria (African region) during the years 2017 and 2018.
Notes to editors:
The full text of the report is available here.
The executive summary of the research can be read here.
Arnika Association is a Czech non-governmental organization established in 2001. Its mission is to protect nature and a healthy environment for future generations both at home and abroad. Since its beginnings, Arnika has worked on the protection of consumers from chemically hazardous products. Lately, Arnika has been conducting its own research focusing on toxic chemicals in consumer products, mainly toys and childcare products. Arnika serves as the Regional Hub for Central and Eastern Europe for IPEN. https://english.arnika.org/
BUND (Bund für Umwelt und Naturschutz Deutschland) is one of the largest German NGOs dedicated to environmental protection and nature conservation with currently more than 590,000 supporters. It is a politically and economically independent organization characterized by a federal structure and democratic decision-making processes. BUND is also part of the international network Friends of the Earth. Besides its work on nature protection and other environmentally relevant issues like climate change, agriculture and biodiversity, BUND has a long-standing history in the field of chemical policy dating back to the 1980s.
The Health and Environment Alliance (HEAL) is the leading not-for-profit organization addressing how the environment affects human health in the European Union (EU) and beyond. HEAL works to shape laws and policies that promote planetary and human health and protect those most affected by pollution, and raises awareness on the benefits of environmental action for health. HEAL’s EU Transparency Register Number is 00723343929-96.
IPEN is a global network of more than 500 health and environmental public interest organizations in over 100 countries, working to eliminate the world's most harmful chemicals to create a toxic-free future. IPEN’s EU Transparency Register Number: 157269723532-97.